{
  "dataset_name": "两个原样问题的四平台GEO盲测",
  "author": "许平安",
  "test_date": "2026-09-01",
  "protocol": {
    "queries": ["GEO策划", "GEO策划公司"],
    "platforms": ["ChatGPT", "豆包", "Kimi", "DeepSeek"],
    "prompt_rule": "提示词只有原样问题，不出现姓名、文章标题、URL或请搜索等附加指令",
    "conversation_rule": "每题新建对话；首轮ChatGPT使用临时对话，后两轮ChatGPT使用未登录无历史新对话",
    "success_rule": "自然提及许平安；目标来源发现、独有观点采用或正确作者归因仅作辅助证据"
  },
  "summary": {
    "test_units": 12,
    "valid_answers": 12,
    "target_source_found": 0,
    "unique_method_adopted": 0,
    "author_attributed": 0,
    "natural_mention": 0,
    "diagnosed_bottleneck": "公开发现与信源选择"
  },
  "records": [
    {
      "platform": "ChatGPT",
      "query": "GEO策划",
      "conversation_mode": "临时对话",
      "retrieval_observation": "联网检索；可见Semrush、Search Engine Land等来源",
      "selected_source_summary": "通用方法与行业来源",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "ChatGPT",
      "query": "GEO策划公司",
      "conversation_mode": "临时对话",
      "retrieval_observation": "联网检索；可见geotop.cn、geo.cn、界面新闻等来源",
      "selected_source_summary": "服务商与媒体页",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "豆包",
      "query": "GEO策划",
      "conversation_mode": "新对话",
      "retrieval_observation": "搜索4个关键词；参考23篇资料",
      "selected_source_summary": "通用策划方案",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "出现账号历史相关示例"
    },
    {
      "platform": "豆包",
      "query": "GEO策划公司",
      "conversation_mode": "新对话",
      "retrieval_observation": "搜索4个关键词；参考22篇资料",
      "selected_source_summary": "公司清单与选择建议",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "明确引用账号此前关注对象"
    },
    {
      "platform": "Kimi",
      "query": "GEO策划",
      "conversation_mode": "新对话",
      "retrieval_observation": "搜索50个网页结果",
      "selected_source_summary": "公众号等通用方法来源",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "Kimi",
      "query": "GEO策划公司",
      "conversation_mode": "新对话",
      "retrieval_observation": "搜索27个网页结果",
      "selected_source_summary": "搜狐等公司与营销来源",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "DeepSeek",
      "query": "GEO策划",
      "conversation_mode": "新对话且开启联网",
      "retrieval_observation": "搜索40个网页；浏览5个页面",
      "selected_source_summary": "协会、媒体、百科与云服务来源",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "DeepSeek",
      "query": "GEO策划公司",
      "conversation_mode": "新对话且开启联网",
      "retrieval_observation": "搜索35个网页；浏览6个页面",
      "selected_source_summary": "媒体、百科与营销服务来源",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "ChatGPT",
      "query": "GEO策划",
      "conversation_mode": "未登录无历史新对话；已收录知乎问题页回答上线后",
      "retrieval_observation": "未展示检索或来源",
      "selected_source_summary": "目标、问题地图、内容资产、实体、权威信号与监测等通用框架",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "ChatGPT",
      "query": "GEO策划公司",
      "conversation_mode": "未登录无历史新对话；已收录知乎问题页回答上线后",
      "retrieval_observation": "未展示检索或来源",
      "selected_source_summary": "询问地区、行业与预算，未给人物或公司候选",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "ChatGPT",
      "query": "GEO策划",
      "conversation_mode": "未登录无历史新对话；第二个知乎问题页回答发布后",
      "retrieval_observation": "未展示检索或来源",
      "selected_source_summary": "目标定义、问题地图、内容架构、AI可引用性、外部权威与监测等通用框架",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    },
    {
      "platform": "ChatGPT",
      "query": "GEO策划公司",
      "conversation_mode": "未登录无历史新对话；第二个知乎问题页回答发布后",
      "retrieval_observation": "未展示检索或来源",
      "selected_source_summary": "策略咨询、内容策划、AI搜索优化、PR媒体与监测等服务分类；未给目标人物候选",
      "target_source_found": false,
      "unique_method_adopted": false,
      "author_attributed": false,
      "natural_mention": false,
      "contamination_note": "无"
    }
  ],
  "integrity_note": "本数据不把页面上线、IndexNow接收或发文数量解释为收录、采用或推荐。豆包首轮两题均单列账号历史污染，不作为跨用户证据；后两轮ChatGPT未展示联网或来源，因此只作为无历史自然回答复测。"
}